Unfair: The New Science of Criminal Injustice (Reviewed)

unfair

Another important read in the all-too-real world of wrongful conviction.

Benforado takes an approach that I haven’t come across yet. He spends a lot of time bringing forward psychological studies and applies them to our criminal justice system. The science behind why our system fails us so often is very closely tied to our human tendency to believe with full conviction that we are capable of setting aside our biases (including hosts of biases and false beliefs that we don’t even know we have) and coming to “the truth.” Our belief that our system can and does offer sufficient safeguards against error gives us an inflated and deceptively cool assurance that we have indeed provided “justice,” when in fact our system is rife with error at practically every level of action: from the police and investigative level, to the prosecution and defense actions prior to trial, to the jury trial (if it occurs at all) and or plea bargaining/sentencing.

See the science behind why false confessions occur, better understand how and why “eye witness” testimony is often contrary and inconsistent with the real events, and learn how police interrogations and “line ups” including photo arrays can often lead to mis-identifications without any mal-intent on behalf of the officers – it’s part of their training.

You’ll see how the problem facing our justice system is systemic and deep, and how it’s not at all a matter of “a few bad apples,” but that even the vast majority of the players on BOTH sides of our legal system (generally good men and women with good intentions) are so caught up behind walls of flawed thinking, biases, prejudices, and “us/them” mentalities, as well as many other hurdles to the truth, that they so often fly far afield from actual justice.

These erroneous systemic modes of thought have allowed the justice system to become a big chess game: one where those with money and influence (and light skin, generally) are victorious, and those without money, those marginalized by society (and generally dark skinned) fall prey to the massive wheels of “due process.”

Benforado, in the latter sections of the book, offers some examples of alternative systems that could function as paradigm shifts for our judicial process. I will say that some of them are quite radical, but I can’t say that he’s wrong just because they’re so adverse to what I have grown up with and known as an American in the modern generation. He makes a lot of comparisons to judicial systems in Germany and in Norway – systems that focus not on punishing criminals but on rehabilitating them. These are systems that foster human connection, where criminals are still closely tied to their families so that they don’t lose the social support network that will help them stay out of prison once they’re released. Many of these ideas are all too easily scoffed at, but I think that the time has come for us to give them a shot in our country. The bottom line is that our system is broken, and doing things the way we always have is not bringing about the change that we need.

One of the more radical ideas (the author even admits as much) is abolishing the in-courtroom trial process completely. Benforado makes the argument that a virtual, literally online, trial process could most effectively negate many of the false belief errors that are rife in our system as it currently stands, and that he highlights at length in the book. So instead of the in-person, all in one room trial that we’re so used to seeing in legal dramas, we would have a trial mediated through a computer interface, so that the jury would be viewing the case forensically. Instead of seeing the actual victim, the jury would be seeing an icon; instead of seeing the jury, the attorneys would be seeing icons; instead of the common misdirections included in court trials, such as the handsomeness or not of the defendant, the racial biases, the class and social biases, even the appeal of the victim – all would be mitigated through a generic interface, leaving the jury to focus on the facts of the case as they are presented via audio, text, video, etc. Note is made of advances in technology – for example, the ability to take a panoramic, 360 degree, fully searchable video of the crime scene, which could be required protocol for all crime scene investigations. This video could be shot immediately after the crime and used throughout the trial, making the facts of the crime scene less susceptible to the faulty memories of those witnesses and/or police officers who will sometimes take the stand months or years later, having to describe the crime scene as they remember it.

It might seem as if this “virtual trial” process is mere fantasy, never to be more than wishful thinking, and I agree that implementing such a change would be nothing short of revolutionary in our country, but it’s important to get the idea out there so that perhaps future generations can move closer to a better system than we currently have  – a system that fails millions every year.

 

Please read this book, all of you.

397 thoughts on “Unfair: The New Science of Criminal Injustice (Reviewed)

  1. Pingback: viagra sales

  2. Pingback: cialis generic name

  3. Pingback: printable cialis coupon

  4. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  5. Pingback: top ed pills

  6. Pingback: erectile dysfunction medication

  7. Pingback: impotence pills

  8. Pingback: walmart pharmacy

  9. Pingback: walmart pharmacy

  10. Pingback: canadian pharmacy

  11. Pingback: generic cialis

  12. Pingback: Cialis in usa

  13. Pingback: vardenafil

  14. Pingback: levitra 20 mg

  15. Pingback: levitra canada

  16. Pingback: casino games

  17. Pingback: generic viagra

  18. Pingback: online casino games real money

  19. Pingback: real casino online

  20. Pingback: loans online

  21. Pingback: online payday loans

  22. Pingback: viagra for sale

  23. Pingback: 5 mg cialis

  24. Pingback: cialis to buy

  25. Pingback: cialis 5 mg

  26. Pingback: cialis to buy

  27. Pingback: Bovada

  28. Pingback: bingo for cash prizes

  29. Pingback: viagra sildenafil

  30. Pingback: online casino

  31. Pingback: online casino games

  32. Pingback: online casino real money usa

  33. Pingback: generic viagra reviews

  34. Pingback: viagra canada

  35. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg

  36. Pingback: cheap viagra

  37. Pingback: viagra price

  38. Pingback: brand viagra

  39. Pingback: buy viagra online canada

  40. Pingback: real viagra without doctor prescription

  41. Pingback: buy viagra without prescription

  42. Pingback: save sources to buy viagra from

  43. Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine online uk

  44. http://grassfed.us/

    It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d certainly donate to this fantastic blog!
    I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
    I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this website
    with my Facebook group. Chat soon! http://grassfed.us/

    Reply
  45. Pingback: viagra for sale

  46. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  47. Pingback: cialis prices

  48. www.bee-rich.com

    Greetings from California! I’m bored at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch break.
    I enjoy the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home.

    I’m shocked at how quick your blog loaded on my phone ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, great site! http://www.bee-rich.com/

    Reply
  49. Pingback: cialistodo.com

  50. Januarymooh

    Hi would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re utilizing? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most. Can you recommend a good hosting provider at a fair price? Cheers, I appreciate it!

    Reply
  51. Pingback: tadalafil 20mg

  52. Pingback: viagra dosage

  53. Pingback: buying generic viagra online

  54. Pingback: over the counter erectile dysfunction medicine

  55. Pingback: cheap viagra no prescription

  56. Pingback: essay writer reviews

  57. Pingback: writer of the federalist papers

  58. Pingback: professional essay writing service

  59. Pingback: female viagra south africa

  60. Pingback: motivation for homework

  61. Pingback: can i buy sildenafil online

  62. Pingback: symbicort inhaler without prescription

  63. Pingback: how to buy differin 15g

  64. Pingback: diltiazem online pharmacy

  65. Pingback: elavil 50 mg without prescription

  66. Pingback: garcinia cambogia 100caps purchase

  67. Pingback: imdur 40 mg australia

  68. Pingback: imitrex 25mg online pharmacy

  69. Pingback: imodium nz

  70. Pingback: Source

  71. Pingback: indocin nz

  72. Pingback: luvox 50mg tablets

  73. Pingback: macrobid 50mg online

  74. Pingback: order meclizine

  75. Pingback: buy mestinon

  76. Pingback: micardis 40mg online

  77. Pingback: motrin for sale

  78. Pingback: cheapest risperdal 2 mg

  79. Pingback: zithromax 500 mg over the counter

  80. Pingback: clonidine online pharmacy

  81. Pingback: ciprofloxacin online

  82. Pingback: clindamycin 150mg without a prescription

  83. Pingback: desmopressin for sale

  84. Pingback: bisacodyl 5 mg over the counter

  85. Pingback: cheap venlafaxine

  86. Pingback: amitriptyline 25mg tablet

  87. Pingback: permethrin purchase

  88. Pingback: erythromycin 500 mg generic

  89. Pingback: buy estradiol 2mg

  90. Pingback: tamsulosinmg otc

  91. Pingback: fluticasone 50 mcg united states

  92. Pingback: where to buy nitrofurantoin 100mg

  93. Pingback: glipizide nz

  94. Pingback: isosorbide 30mg nz

  95. Pingback: azathioprine 25 mg over the counter

  96. Pingback: where to buy propranolol 20 mg

  97. Pingback: terbinafine 250mg cheap

  98. Pingback: levothyroxine mcg pharmacy

  99. Pingback: clotrimazole cheap

  100. Pingback: how to purchase metoclopramide

  101. generic clomid over the counter

    Can alluring prenatal clomiphene for men refrain from you conceive? Fascinating a prenatal vitamin, in reckoning to eating fruits, vegetables, rangy meat and strong grains, can resist you win your body healthy and in proper shape to conceive. On this saneness, myriad doctors lead one to believe irresistible prenatal Clomid some time ago you start troublesome for the sake of a baby.

    Reply
  102. cialis pills

    Do I need a prescription fitting for discount tadalafil. Since tadalafil is just to hand on formula, you’ll difficulty to unalloyed an online consultation with an non-partisan physician in the forefront your categorization is shipped. If you’re a good office-seeker, you’ll make a valid preparation in search order cialis online online.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *